B. A. 1st Sem, Unit: I, Political Science, Class Notes, According to KU- NEP Syllabus

Unit I:  Concepts: Politics, Political Philosophy, Political Thought, Political Theory, Political Science. 

By

Dr. Farzeen Bano

Politics

Origin and Meaning

- The term "politics" is derived from the Greek word “polis”, meaning a city-state in ancient Greece.

- Aristotle referred to politics as the “master science” because it governs all aspects of human life.  

Definitions of Politics

1. Aristotle: “Politics is the study of the affairs of the polis or state.”

2. David Easton: “Politics is the authoritative allocation of values.”

3. Harold Lasswell: “Politics is who gets what, when, and how.”

4. Andrew Heywood: “Politics is the activity through which people make, preserve, and amend the general rules under which they live.”

- Politics involves decision-making, distribution of resources, and governance within a group or society.

Scope

1. State and Government: Structure, processes, and functions of institutions.

2. Power and Authority: Study of power dynamics and legitimacy.

3. Political Behavior: Analysis of political attitudes and participation.

4. Public Policies: Formulation and implementation of rules and laws.

Significance

- Politics ensures social order, justice, and economic stability.

- It helps reconcile conflicting interests and resolves disputes.

- Politics shapes laws, policies, and governance structures.

---Political Philosophy--

Origin and Meaning

- The term "philosophy" comes from the Greek words “philo” (love) and “sophia” (wisdom), meaning "love of wisdom."

- Political philosophy examines fundamental questions about governance, justice, rights, and duties.

Definitions of Philosophy

1. Leo Strauss: “Political philosophy seeks to know the political good.”

2. Bertrand Russell: “Philosophy is the science of logical analysis of concepts.”

3. Andrew Heywood: “Political philosophy is concerned with the ideas and principles that underpin political systems.”

Importance

- Political philosophy provides ethical frameworks for evaluating laws and policies.

- It investigates the nature of justice, liberty, and equality.

  Major Philosophical Traditions

1. Classical Political Philosophy: Plato’s ideal state, Aristotle’s mixed government.

2. Modern Political Philosophy: Social contract theories (Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau).

3. Contemporary Political Philosophy: Rawls’ theory of justice, Nozick’s libertarianism.

 --Political Thought--

Origin and Meaning

- Political thought refers to the body of ideas and theories about politics and governance developed over time.

- It includes the works of philosophers, theorists, and political leaders.

Definitions of Political Thought

1. George H. Sabine: “Political thought is the history of the ideas of men about society and the authority of the state.”

2. O.P. Gauba: “Political thought explores how political communities and their institutions should be organized.”

Overview

- Political thought analyzes the evolution of political ideas across eras:

  1. Ancient: Plato, Aristotle.

  2. Medieval: St. Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas.

  3. Modern: Machiavelli, Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau.

  4. Contemporary: Marx, Gandhi, Ambedkar.

Historical Evolution

- Ancient political thought emphasized ideal states and virtues.

- Modern political thought focused on sovereignty and individual rights.

- Contemporary thought addresses issues like socialism, feminism, and globalization.

---4. Political Theory--

Origin and Meaning

- Derived from the Greek word “theoria”, meaning speculation or contemplation.

- Political theory involves systematic thinking about political concepts and their implications.

Definitions of Political Theory

1. Andrew Heywood: “Political theory is a body of knowledge aimed at developing knowledge about politics.”

2. O.P. Gauba: “Political theory is a science that explains and evaluates political phenomena.”

Types

1. Normative Theory: Prescriptive; focuses on what ought to be (e.g., Rawls’ justice theory).

2. Empirical Theory: Descriptive; focuses on what is (e.g., behavioralism).

3. Critical Theory: Challenges existing systems (e.g., Marxism, feminism).

Relevance

- Political theory provides frameworks to analyze political systems.

- It helps develop principles for better governance.

---5. Political Science--

Origin and Meaning

- The term "science" indicates a systematic study. Political science emerged as a distinct discipline in the 19th century.

- Political science analyzes the structure and functioning of political institutions and processes.

Definitions 

1. Aristotle: “Political science is the study of the state.”

2. David Easton: “Political science is the study of the allocation of values within a society.”

3. O.P. Gauba: “Political science is the discipline that studies politics, governance, and the state.”

Nature of Political Science

Political Science: An Art or a Science?

Political Science has been debated as either an art or a science for centuries. This debate arises due to its dual characteristics: its focus on empirical evidence and systematic study (science) versus its reliance on subjective judgments, creativity, and ethical considerations (art).

1. Political Science as a Science

Political Science qualifies as a science because it employs systematic methods to study political phenomena. The emphasis is on objectivity, observation, and evidence-based analysis.

Arguments Supporting Political Science as a Science:

1. Systematic Study: Like natural sciences, Political Science uses methods like data collection, hypothesis formulation, and statistical analysis.

2. Predictability: It tries to predict political behavior and outcomes based on historical and empirical data.

3. Generalizations: Political Science formulates general theories, such as the theory of democracy, which apply across nations.

4. Empirical Research: It relies on field surveys, case studies, and quantitative methods to study voter behavior, policy impacts, and institutional performance.

Supporters of Political Science as a Science:

- Aristotle

- David Easton

- Harold Lasswell 

- Karl Deutsch

2. Political Science as an Art

Political Science is also seen as an art because it involves creativity, subjective interpretation, and moral judgment. Politics often deals with abstract concepts like justice, liberty, and rights, which cannot always be quantified.

Arguments Supporting Political Science as an Art:

1. Practical Application: Politics is about real-world problem-solving and decision-making, requiring judgment and persuasion.

2. Value Orientation: Political Science deals with normative questions, such as "What is the ideal form of government?"

3. Complex Human Behavior: Human actions in politics are influenced by emotions, culture, and ethics, which are difficult to analyze scientifically.

4. Diplomacy and Leadership: Political practitioners must use intuition, negotiation, and charisma, reflecting the artistic side of politics.

Supporters of Political Science as an Art:

- Machiavelli 

-Edmund Burke

-Woodrow Wilson

3. Dual Nature: A Science and an Art

Many scholars argue that Political Science is both an art and a science, combining empirical research with subjective interpretation and practical application.

Blending Science and Art:

- Scientific Aspects: Analysis of political institutions, voting behavior, and public opinion.

- Artistic Aspects: Political leadership, public administration, and diplomacy involve human emotions and values.

Supporters of the Dual Nature:

-Max Weber

- Robert Dahl 

Conclusion

Political Science embodies characteristics of both an art and a science. While its scientific dimension ensures systematic study and predictability, its artistic side addresses the subjective, ethical, and practical aspects of governance and political leadership. The dual nature enriches its scope and ensures its relevance in understanding and shaping human society.

Scope

The scope of Political Science has expanded significantly over time as it addresses fundamental questions about power, authority, governance, and the functioning of political systems. Below is a detailed explanation of its scope:

1. Study of the State: Origin, development, and functions.
2. Government: It analyzes the organization and functioning of legislative, executive, and judicial branches.
3. Constitution: Understanding the constitution as the framework within which governments operate is also central to the discipline. 
4. Political Systems: Types, structures, and functioning.
5. International Relations: IR explores the relationships between nations, focusing on: diplomacy, conflicts, global governance, treaties, global organizations like the UN, WTO, and WHO, issues like war, peace, trade, and environmental cooperation, theories like Realism, Liberalism, and Constructivism.  Diplomacy, 
6. Study of Public Administration: As a subfield, it examines the functioning of bureaucracies and public policies. This includes the principles of organization, decision-making, and governance, with an emphasis on efficiency and service delivery.
7. Globalization and Regionalism: Examines the impact of global integration and regional alliances like the EU or ASEAN.
8. Environmental Politics: Addresses issues like climate change and sustainable development.
9. Cyber Politics: Studies the role of technology and social media in modern governance and elections.
10. Women and Gender Studies: Focuses on gender equality and political participation of women.
11. Political Economy: This area explores the interaction between economics and politics.
12. Political Sociology: This examines the relationship between society and politics, the role of social factors like caste, class, religion, and gender in politics.
13. Study of Rights and Justice: Political Science analyzes fundamental rights, liberties, and justice systems, focusing on human rights, civil rights movements, and the rule of law.
14. Role of Political Institutions: It studies the functioning of political institutions like: Parliaments and Congresses, political parties and electoral systems, interest groups and pressure groups. 
15. Study of Political Theories: Political Science delves into classical and modern political theories. These theories provide frameworks for understanding the principles guiding political behavior and systems.
16. Comparative Politics: This branch studies the comparison of different political systems, institutions, and practices worldwide. It helps identify similarities and differences in governance, policy-making, and state structures across countries. 

 Conclusion  

The scope of Political Science continues to evolve with global political developments and societal changes. It remains relevant in addressing issues of governance, power dynamics, and public welfare.

Differences between these terms

1. Politics vs Political Philosophy 

Differences could be understand on the following grounds: 

- Meaning: Politics refers to practical activities like governance, power relations, and decision-making, dealing with the "what is." Political philosophy is a theoretical field exploring normative questions like justice, liberty, and equality, dealing with the "what ought to be."  

- Nature: Politics is action-oriented and dynamic, involving real-world activities such as elections and governance. Political philosophy is speculative and focuses on abstract principles and ideals.  

- Scope: Politics addresses governance, statecraft, and resource allocation. Political philosophy examines the moral and ethical foundations of governance.  

- Focus: Politics emphasizes day-to-day political operations, while political philosophy explores the broader ethical and philosophical underpinnings of these operations.  

- Example: Politics involves activities like political parties strategizing for elections, whereas political philosophy discusses concepts like Plato’s “Ideal State” or John Rawls’ “Theory of Justice.”  

2. Political Thought vs Political Theory

Differences could be understand on the following grounds:  

- Meaning: Political thought is the historical evolution of ideas and ideologies about governance, focusing on thinkers like Aristotle or Rousseau. Political theory is a systematic analysis of political concepts and phenomena, often rooted in empirical and normative studies.  

- Nature: Political thought is descriptive and evolutionary, focusing on how ideas have developed over time. Political theory is analytical and logical, addressing specific political issues or concepts.  

- Scope: Political thought emphasizes the contributions of individual thinkers or traditions. Political theory explores broader frameworks like behavioralism, pluralism, or theories of power.  

- Approach: Political thought takes a historical and descriptive approach, while political theory adopts a systematic and evaluative approach.  

- Example: Political thought includes ideas like Rousseau’s social contract or Gandhian ideology, while political theory encompasses concepts like pluralist theory or Weber’s authority.  

3. Political Philosophy vs Political Theory

Differences could be understand on the following grounds: 

- Meaning: Political philosophy is a branch of philosophy that deals with normative ideals like justice and liberty. Political theory is a subfield of political science that analyzes and explains political concepts and phenomena.  

- Nature: Political philosophy is speculative, dealing with metaphysical and ethical inquiry. Political theory is both empirical and normative, combining observation with prescription.  

- Focus: Political philosophy explores universal principles and ideals. Political theory focuses on specific concepts such as power, authority, and legitimacy.  

- Example: Political philosophy includes Hobbes’ exploration of human nature in Leviathan. Political theory covers theories like Dahl’s concept of polyarchy or Marxist theory.  

4. Politics vs Political Science

Differences could be understand on the following grounds: 

- Meaning: Politics is the practice of governance, involving power struggles and conflict resolution. Political science is the academic study of political systems, institutions, and behavior.  

- Nature: Politics is dynamic and practical, focusing on real-world political activities. Political science is systematic and theoretical, focusing on understanding political phenomena.  

- Scope: Politics focuses on the implementation and management of power, laws, and policies. Political science explores theories, institutions, and comparative studies of political systems.  

- Methods: Politics uses informal methods like negotiations and power plays. Political science adopts scientific methods, including observation, analysis, and hypothesis testing.  

- Example: Politics involves activities like campaigning or forming coalitions. Political science involves comparative studies of different political systems, such as democracy and autocracy.  

5. Political Science vs Political Theory

Differences could be understand on the following grounds: 

- Meaning: Political science is the systematic study of political systems, governance, and institutions. Political theory is the theoretical framework used to analyze and interpret political concepts.  

- Nature: Political science is a broader discipline covering institutions, processes, and global relations. Political theory is a subfield focusing on ideologies, principles, and conceptual debates.  

- Scope: Political science includes areas like international relations, public administration, and comparative politics. Political theory deals with concepts like liberty, equality, and justice.  

- Example: Political science involves studying federalism or parliamentary systems. Political theory includes frameworks like feminism, Marxism, or realism.  

6. Politics vs Political Thought

Differences could be understand on the following grounds: 

- Meaning: Politics involves the practice of governance and decision-making within a society. Political thought refers to the historical evolution of political ideas and ideologies.  

- Focus: Politics focuses on real-world applications of power, laws, and policies. Political thought examines the origins and development of political concepts over time.  

- Nature: Politics is action-oriented and dynamic, dealing with conflicts, negotiations, and power struggles. Political thought is idea-oriented and descriptive, focusing on the writings and ideologies of key thinkers.  

- Example: Politics includes activities like legislative debates or coalition-building. Political thought covers contributions like Aristotle’s classification of governments or Gandhi’s vision of non-violence.  

Summary

These distinctions highlight the relationships and differences between practical and theoretical aspects of politics, ranging from day-to-day governance to normative ideals and systematic studies.

------------------------------------

Sharing is caring: Share it with your known.